Danger of Too Much Training {Say less. Pray more}

Mar 28, 2012

I had an “ah-ha”parenting moment. I picked up the book “Hints on Child Training” by H. Clay Trumbull. Two older moms (including Sally Clarkson) recommended the book. H. Clay Trumbull, father of eight children & the great-grandfather of Elisabeth Elliot, wrote it in 1890. The advice he gives is Bible-centered, wise & applicable to children of any generation.

In my usual non-fiction reading habit, I flipped through the book and started reading a chapter that caught my eye. The chapter was entitled: “Letting Alone as a Means of Child Training.”

“Child training is a necessity, but there is a danger of overdoing in the line of child training.  The neglect of child training is a great evil. Overdoing in the training of a child may be even a greater evil.” -H. Clay Trumbull

Let that sink in for a second. No training is evil BUT over-training may be a greater evil.

I always judged those who gave their children no boundaries or discipline, as “bad parents”. But in reality I’m the one to be judged in my “over-training”.

“The young parents who are exceptionally conscientious, and exceptionally desirous of being wise and faithful in the discharge of their parental duties, are liable to err in the direction of overdoing in the training of their children.” -H. Clay Trumbull

In this stage of adding a new baby, I desire control over my kids more than ever. So I increase my training & direction. Fooling myself into the belief that I’m actually in control. The reality is that the more I direct & correct the more I push them to misbehavior. I don’t end up training their hearts.

Here is the advice of one father in his experience with his oldest child:

“I thought I must be training her all the time, and I forced issues with her, and took notice of little things, when I would have done better to leave her alone… I saw my mistake afterwards, and I allowed my other children more freedom, by letting them alone except when they must be interfered with; and I’ve seen the benefit of this course”

After reading this chapter I made a pact with myself…I would turn a “blind eye” to minor infractions of my boys. When one was too rough I would NOT remind him to be gentle. When they use potty talk I would NOT remind them to use “life-giving” words. I would NOT remind them to shut the back door.

photo credit

Oh my goodness is it hard! It’s become such a habit for me to correct all day long. AND it’s become a habit for them to wait for me to correct before they change their behavior. 

I realized they’ve become dependent on my words to direct their actions. Their internal monitors for behavior control were turned “off”. All behavior control was external. Not what I want. I can’t be with them at all times. They need to regulate their own behavior.

I also realized that when I didn’t direct them and allowed them to make the right choice, I could reinforce their good choice. Give them credit & positive reinforcement. In the past they were just doing what I asked, now they were doing it on their own…which is true training.

My mentor, Leslie, gave me the advice: “Use fewer words. Pray more.”  In those moments when I’m trying to hold my tongue, I pray.

I pray for the particular character quality. I pray for wisdom to know whether I should intervene. I pray for God to put a guard over my mouth and give me self-control.

Do you struggle with over-training your children? Are you primarily directing/correcting? Will you join me in the “pact” to say less & pray more?


  1. Patti

    “Use fewer words. Pray more.” That just says it all!

  2. fbic72

    I am an over trainer..I needed to hear this so badly….THANK YOU for posting it..Im with you on this pact!

  3. fbic72

    I am an over trainer..I needed to read this so badly..THANK YOU for posting it…I am joining the Use fewer words. Pray More pact 🙂

  4. Amy K.

    Whenever I read your blog I feel like you are going through so much of the same that I am going through. Thank you for your post today! I definitely am over-training my children and it is exhausting me and them. I do pray throughout my day for guidance from God so that I can make the choices with my children that God would want me to make. I think I need to insert more prayer though so that the over-training will calm down a bit.

  5. Angie

    I will join you:)

  6. staciesmith19

    Great post! Thanks for sharing. I love your blog.

    Stacie Smith


  1. French Lesson #2: The “Cadre” {Say Less, Pray More} | God centered mom - [...] few weeks ago I wrote about my latest realization…overtraining my boys (saying too much & not praying enough). Since writing…
  2. The Words that Carried Me in 2012 | God centered mom - [...] Say Less, Pray More. [...]
  3. Faith, Prayer…and boys | God centered mom - […] A few years ago after a long day home with the boys I called my friend/boymom mentor Leslie asking…

Pin It on Pinterest